Why is it that some businesses are more successful that others? Why do some start and fold like a firework rocket exploding in the night sky while others seem to last the test of time? The answer is simple - successful businesses have some sort of competitive advantage they can defend against the onslaught of competitors.
What is Competitive Advantage
Put simply, competitive advantage is anything your firm has or does that makes it better than your competitors in the eyes of your customers. Perhaps you’ve got a great location, lower costs, better service levels or more money in the bank that the other guy. Every business needs some sort of competitive advantage in order to survive but unfortunately that’s not enough. To survive and prosper in the long run, you need some kind of advantage that is difficult for your competitor to buy, copy or learn; and one that is easy for you to defend. You need a Sustainable Competitive Advantage.
Competitive advantage can take many forms. According to the resource based theory, firms are collections of resources - physical, reputational, organisational, financial, intellectual & technological - the combinations of which offer some level of advantage against competitors. Occasionally, these resources may offer a sustainable competitive advantage because they are valuable, rare, hard to copy and non-substitutable.
Sustainable Competitive Advantage in Hostel Distribution
There are hundreds of hostel booking engines on available on line and like most industries, the distribution of revenue amongst them is anything but even. In this case, the online booking channel is dominated by HostelWorld and HostelBookers and between them, they account for the vast majority of online hostel intermediary sales.
How did it get this way? Well,it wasn’t because they were the best. Just like the superior Betamax technology loosing out to VHS, there are much better booking systems available that don’t generate nearly as much revenue. Their navigation is poor and both sites look very out dated. Neither fulfil the customers needs completely - there isn’t enough information to make a properly informed buying decision for example.
Interestingly, their success has more to do with the limitations of hostels than anything they do themselves. These sites rely on heavily on network effects - the more users they have, the more inventory hostels will give them and the more inventory they have, the more users they can attract. Inventory, and the time it takes hostels to load it into the various systems, turns out to be a valuable resources. Hostel owners are busy people who will only spend the time loading rates if they can expect bookings in return, making it rare, hard to copy and non-substitutable (a new booking engine can’t just invent more availability!) - all the attributes needed for sustainable competitive advantage. Even more interesting, the source of their sustainable competitive advantage is something that they don’t even own, yet can still defend.
Businesses that rely on network effects for competitive advantage need first mover advantage. HostelWorld started in 1999 and HostelBookers in 2002. Because they were first, they have always been the ‘biggest’, even when they were quite small. This created a virtuous cirlce of more traffic = more inventory = more traffic until the point today where access to inventory is the single biggest barrier to entry for competitors. HostelWorld and HostelBookers will remain the dominant players until a competitor or new technology changes the rules of the game.
Even sustainable advantage isn’t permanent
While it might be called sustainable, the sources of advantage can quickly change. The great thing about market competition is that it drive innovation and new technologies and processes can quickly change the rules of the game - just ask Kodak or Ford. In the case of HostelWorld, their advantage would be quickly diminished if the time and availability constraint of loading inventory was reduced. Perhaps a group of smaller competitors could band together and develop a standard interface where hostel inventory could be updated once and exported to all booking engines? This would be a serious blow for HostelWorld and would force them to compete on different terms.
So what’s your business’ competitive advantage? Is it sustainable? Remember, the only truly sustainable advantage (short of government fiat) is the ability to innovate faster than competitors.